Manchester City and the 115 Charges: The Case That Could Alter the History of English Football

Manchester City and the 115 Charges: The Case That Could Alter the History of English Football




For almost eight years, Manchester City have operated under the shadow of an investigation that has become one of the most consequential disputes in the history of English football.

The case began not with the Premier League's decision to charge the club, but with a cache of confidential football documents obtained through Football Leaks and examined by journalists at the German publication Der Spiegel. The material raised questions about Manchester City's sponsorship income, payments to senior figures and the financial relationship between the club and organisations connected to its Abu Dhabi ownership.

What followed was a chain of investigations that eventually reached UEFA, the Court of Arbitration for Sport and, ultimately, the Premier League.

In February 2023, the Premier League charged Manchester City with 115 alleged breaches of its financial regulations. The allegations covered the period from the 2009/10 season through 2017/18, together with separate allegations concerning the club's conduct during the Premier League's subsequent investigation.

The case was heard by an independent commission between September and December 2024.

Nearly two years later, the first major ruling has emerged.

According to reports published on 25 September 2026, the commission found Manchester City guilty of 114 of the 115 charges. The full written decision and the resulting sanctions have not yet been made public, and Manchester City continue to contest the allegations and are expected to appeal.

That distinction is important. Manchester City have not been relegated. Their titles have not been stripped. No points deduction has been imposed. No player has been ordered to leave the club.

Those questions belong to the next stage of the case.

To understand what is now at stake, however, it is necessary to go back to the beginning.


The origins of the case

Manchester City's transformation began in 2008, when Sheikh Mansour's Abu Dhabi United Group acquired the club. The investment changed City's position in English football and, over the following decade, helped establish the club as one of Europe's leading sides.

The expansion coincided with the introduction of UEFA's Financial Fair Play system and increasingly detailed financial regulations within English football. The principle behind those rules was straightforward: clubs should not be permitted to sustain spending levels indefinitely through owner funding without demonstrating corresponding and permissible revenues.

It was against this background that the documents obtained through Football Leaks became significant.

Portuguese national Rui Pinto, who operated the Football Leaks platform, obtained a vast collection of confidential football documents. The material was subsequently provided to journalists, including reporters at Der Spiegel, which began publishing its Manchester City investigations in November 2018.

Pinto did not leak a document containing "the 115 charges". Those charges did not yet exist.

What the leaked material did was provide journalists and investigators with documents that raised questions about the way Manchester City had reported certain revenues and payments. Those revelations became an important part of the background to the investigations that followed.

Among the allegations were questions concerning the financing of sponsorship agreements, including arrangements involving Etihad Airways and other companies associated with Abu Dhabi, as well as payments connected with players and former manager Roberto Mancini.

The central issue was not whether Manchester City had received sponsorship revenue. The issue was whether the club's accounts accurately represented the source and nature of that revenue.

That distinction became fundamental to the later Premier League case.


From Football Leaks to UEFA

The leaked material contributed to renewed scrutiny from UEFA, which had already examined Manchester City's finances.

In 2014, City reached a settlement with UEFA concerning Financial Fair Play rules. The issue returned to prominence after the Football Leaks publications.

In February 2020, UEFA imposed a two-season exclusion from European competitions and a €30 million fine on Manchester City. The club appealed to the Court of Arbitration for Sport.

CAS overturned the European ban and reduced the fine to €10 million. It also found that City had failed to cooperate properly with UEFA's investigation.

The decision was significant, but it did not resolve the subsequent Premier League case. The Premier League proceedings were separate, concerned a different regulatory framework and covered a broader period of alleged conduct.


The Premier League investigation

The Premier League began its investigation in December 2018.

It continued for approximately four years before the league formally referred Manchester City to an independent commission on 6 February 2023.

The 115 allegations were divided into several areas. The largest group concerned the alleged failure to provide accurate financial information over nine seasons. Other allegations concerned the reporting of player and manager remuneration, compliance with UEFA regulations, the Premier League's own profitability and sustainability requirements, and the club's alleged failure to cooperate with the investigation.

The figures are significant:

Category| Alleged breaches

Financial information| 54

Player and manager remuneration| 14

UEFA regulations| 5

Premier League PSR| 7

Cooperation with the investigation| 35

Total| 115

The figures should not, however, be interpreted as 115 separate allegations of the same conduct. They represent individual charges arising from several categories of alleged regulatory breaches across different seasons.

At the centre of the financial allegations is a question that has implications far beyond Manchester City: whether the club accurately reported the revenues and expenditure upon which its compliance with financial regulations was assessed.


The hearing

The independent commission began hearing the case on 16 September 2024. Proceedings continued for approximately 12 weeks and concluded on 6 December.

Manchester City assembled a substantial legal team, led by Lord David Pannick KC. The Premier League was represented by its own senior counsel.

The proceedings were conducted privately, and the commission then considered the evidence before reaching its decision.

On 25 September 2026, reports emerged that the commission had found City guilty on 114 of the 115 charges.

The full written judgment remains critical. Until it is published, it is not possible to examine in detail the commission's reasoning on each allegation or to assess precisely how it treated the individual strands of the Premier League's case.

The distinction between the reported findings and the eventual punishment is equally important.

The commission's determination of liability does not itself establish what Manchester City's sporting or financial punishment will be.


The financial stakes

Manchester City is no longer the club that entered the 2008 takeover.

Its latest published accounts show revenue of £694.1 million for the 2024/25 season. Commercial revenue accounted for £340.4 million, broadcasting generated £278.6 million and matchday activity produced £75.1 million. The club also recorded £95.2 million in income from player sales.

Those figures explain why the financial consequences of any sanction cannot be measured simply by the size of a potential fine.

A substantial monetary penalty would have an obvious cost, but the greater financial consequences could arise if sporting sanctions affected City's access to Premier League or European competition.

Premier League broadcasting distributions, Champions League revenue, commercial exposure and player trading are all interconnected. A serious sporting penalty could therefore produce consequences extending well beyond the initial sanction.


The question of the titles

Perhaps the most politically and emotionally charged issue for supporters concerns Manchester City's Premier League titles.

Three championships were won during the principal period covered by the financial allegations: 2011/12, 2013/14 and 2017/18.

In 2011/12, City finished level on 89 points with Manchester United and won the championship on goal difference.

In 2013/14, City finished on 86 points, four ahead of Liverpool.

In 2017/18, City became the first Premier League side to reach 100 points, finishing 19 points ahead of Manchester United.

If retrospective sporting sanctions were eventually imposed, those seasons would inevitably receive considerable attention.

But there is no automatic rule under which a vacated championship simply passes to the team that finished second.

Whether a title is vacated, reassigned or left vacant would depend on the terms of any eventual decision. The same applies to the European qualification places, prize money and other consequences that could follow from altering a historical league table.

For that reason, it would be premature to describe Manchester United or Liverpool as having "won" a historical title unless the relevant authority formally makes such a determination.

Relegation and the wider league table

The possibility of relegation presents another layer of uncertainty.

A points deduction could potentially place City in the relegation places. Alternatively, an independent commission could impose a more direct sporting sanction.

The consequences for the rest of the league would depend entirely on the form and timing of the punishment.

If a historical table were retrospectively altered, the effects could extend beyond the title race to Champions League qualification, other European places, relegation and financial distributions.

There is no basis at present for claiming that a particular club would automatically be reprieved from relegation or that an additional club would necessarily be relegated.

Those outcomes would have to follow from the eventual regulatory decision.


The players and the squad

A severe sporting sanction would inevitably raise questions about Manchester City's squad.

Players are not automatically released from their contracts because a club is relegated or sanctioned. Their positions would depend on their individual contracts, release clauses and decisions by the players and the club.

The speculation surrounding players such as Erling Haaland therefore needs to be treated separately from the legal case itself.

What is already clear is that Manchester City are undergoing significant sporting change irrespective of the investigation. Pep Guardiola has departed after a decade in charge, Enzo Maresca has taken over and the squad has undergone substantial turnover.

That means the consequences of the verdict will fall on a Manchester City that is already in the process of rebuilding.


What happens now

The next stage is the commission's sanction.

After that, Manchester City are expected to pursue an appeal.

Only once those processes have been completed will the scale of the sporting and financial consequences become clear.

The case has already lasted years. Its final consequences could take considerably longer to establish.

What began with documents obtained through Football Leaks has developed into a dispute involving the financial regulation of elite football, the independence of sponsorship income, the authority of the Premier League and the credibility of its financial rules.

The reported finding of 114 breaches is therefore significant not simply because of the number attached to it.

It raises a much larger question about how English football should regulate clubs with the financial capacity to operate at the highest level of the sport.

Manchester City's history may ultimately be affected by the answer.

But until the written judgment, sanctions and appeals are settled, the most consequential parts of the story remain unresolved.

Comments